Which player has had the better career?

I know who the two players are. And as a Braves fan, I am biased to Player A for obvious reasons. Both players were great in just different ways. I think Player B was overhyped throughout his career because of his playoff success and the team he plays for, but in reality Player A is the more preferable option. I think more GM's would start a franchise with Player A because there are plenty of Player B's in the league who don't get the publicity, but put up comparable numbers. Player B was great for years, but in the end I'll take Player A.